RSS
 

Posts Tagged ‘hoped’

2019 resolutions revisited: what we hoped for, and what we got

01 Jan

Resolutions revisited – what we hoped for, what we got

About this time last year we sat down as a team to write some new year’s resolutions. But not for us – where’s the fun in that? No, we wanted to help our favorite camera and lens manufacturers out, by writing some for them.

Wishful thinking? Sure. Reasonable? Not at all. Borderline condescending, from a group of keyboard warriors who would struggle to complete a moderately complex jigsaw puzzle, let alone make a digital camera? Absolutely.

We didn’t get everything we wanted in 2019, but some of our resolutions / wishes / predictions (just go with us on this one, and don’t think about it too hard) did come true.

Feel free to play along at home via the comments.

Canon

Our 2019 resolutions for Canon:

  • Add IBIS to the RF lineup and update your sensors (or buy Sony’s).
  • Make the RF mount an open standard.
  • Reclaim your ILC video crown – no more cropped 4K!
  • Dump the M-Fn bar…
  • Make the 5D Mark V a true digital EOS 3.
  • Think different – embrace computational photography.

How things panned out: 2.5/6

Our resolutions for Canon in 2019 were ambitious, and probably for the most part unrealistic. What can I say? We’re big picture people.

The RF mount isn’t going to be opened up any time soon (why cede those lens sales to third parties when you don’t have to?), the EOS 5D Mark IV wasn’t really due for an upgrade, and while we know that IBIS is coming to the EOS R lineup, it didn’t happen in 2019.

But Canon did develop a very nice new sensor, in the form of the 32MP APS-C sensor used in the EOS 90D and EOS M6 Mark II. Not only does it offer excellent resolution and good dynamic range, it also works with an updated processor to allow for un-cropped 4K video. There are rumors starting to float around of an upscaled version of this sensor coming in the RF line possibly next year, so we’ll see. Canon also (sort of) dumped the M-Fn bar, omitting it from the EOS RP.

It remains to be seen whether the controversial control will be re-introduced in a future R-series model but we won’t be sad if it isn’t. We’re not against the concept of a touch-sensitive control of this kind, we just want one that works.

Fujifilm

Our 2019 resolutions for Fujifilm:

  • Make a full-frame X100 / monochrome X100 / 28mm-equiv X100.
  • Continue improving your face and eye-detection autofocus.
  • Make a proper X70 successor.
  • Refresh your F1.4 primes.
  • Don’t try to palm us off with 15fps ‘4K video’ ever again. For shame.

How things panned out: 2/5

Well, we didn’t see that full-frame X100-series in the end, but honestly that was probably a stretch. Fujifilm was pretty focused on its medium-format GFX range in 2019, but the company did release the unique X-Pro 3 (we didn’t see that one coming!) and update its entry-level X-A7 lineup. We were very pleased to see that the X-A7 finally offers proper 4K video. No more 15fps!

Fujifilm has also continued to work on its autofocus. A major firmware update was released for the X-T3 in spring, specifically aimed at improving face and eye-detection AF performance. Fujifilm has also improved the implementation of Face/Eye AF in the X-Pro 3, which presumably will filter down into future models.

Leica

Our 2019 resolutions for Leica:

  • Stop with the special editions already!
  • Make a Q2 – maybe even with a 35mm lens…
  • Make an M-mount camera with an EVF.
  • Improve service / repair times.

How things panned out: 1.5/4

Asking Leica to stop making special editions is like asking a Kuh not to muh. This year saw the launch of the ‘Safari’ edition M10-P, the Lenny Kravitz ‘Drifter’ edition M Monochrom (with snakeskin finish, no less) three limited edition versions of M-mount lenses, and no fewer than three special edition CLs: ‘Bauhaus’, ‘Urban Jungle’ and ‘Edition Paul Smith’.

Ouch. It’s almost as if Leica wanted to put us in our place.

Meanwhile, although we’re still waiting for an M11 with an EVF, Leica did release the Q2, which comes with some really welcome upgrades compared to the original Q. Ditto the SL. The company also claims to be continuing to invest in improving service times, which, because we’re feeling generous, we’ll say earns them a 0.5.

Nikon

Our 2019 resolutions for Nikon:

  • Keep developing that Z-series lens roadmap.
  • Bring 3D AF Tracking to the Z-series.
  • Make an FTZ adapter with a built-in AF motor.
  • Make the Z mount an open standard.

How things panned out: 1/4

We didn’t do a great job of anticipating Nikon’s moves in 2019, but nobody said that new years’ resolutions were easy, especially when you’re making them for other people. Nikon didn’t add a version of 3D AF tracking to the Z-series this year, but it did introduce a new camera, in the form of the APS-C Z50. Pending some final testing, we’ve been pretty impressed by its performance so far, but it basically has the same autofocus behavior as the Z6 and Z7.

The only one of our resolutions on behalf of Nikon which ended up becoming reality was perhaps the most obvious one – continued development of the Z-mount lens lineup.

We’ve really been impressed by the Z-series lenses so far, and 2019 saw the release of the standout Z 24-70mm F2.8 S and Z 85mm F1.8 S, with more still to come on the roadmap.

Olympus

Our 2019 resolutions for Olympus:

  • Start making small cameras again.
  • Update the OM-D E-M5 II.
  • Simplify your cameras’ menu systems, please!
  • Add PDAF to your lower-end PEN and OM-D cameras.
  • Add a large sensor to the TOUGH range.

How things panned out: 3/5

Olympus didn’t release a whole lot of products this year, but the OM-D E-M5 lineup did see a refresh in the form of the very powerful E-M5 Mark III. Despite being packed with powerful features (many of which were inherited from the E-M1 Mark II) it is even smaller than its predecessor, and features on-sensor phase-detection autofocus.

Sadly it still features a dense and complicated UI / menu, but 3/5 ain’t bad.

Panasonic

Our 2019 resolutions for Panasonic:

  • Ditch field-sequential EVFs.
  • Either fix DFD for video, or use PDAF instead.
  • Make a full-frame 4K video camera.

How things panned out: 2/3

With so many announcements in late 2018, it was hard to make too many specific resolutions for Panasonic in 2019, but the company did check off two items from our wishlist: An (apparent) move away from field-sequential and towards OLED electronic finders, and a full-frame 4K video camera, in the shape of the Lumix DC-S1H.

The S1H is an interesting product, coming so quickly after the launch of the S1R and the more video-oriented S1 – itself a hugely capable camera for shooting video, especially with Panasonic’s paid DMW-SFU2 update. The S1H can shoot perfectly good still images from its 24MP sensor, but it’s really a video-first product, and the first ‘consumer’ camera to be certified by Netflix for broadcast-quality recording. Impressive stuff.

Ricoh / Pentax

Our 2019 resolutions for Ricoh / Pentax:

  • Make a true successor to the K-1.
  • Give your fans a proper mirrorless camera.
  • Make a full-frame GR to compete with the Leica Q and Sony RX1R II.

How things panned out: 0/3

It was a very quiet year for Ricoh in the end, with the GR III the only significant new Pentax-branded product released in 2019 (actually late 2018, but it became available this year).

There were some signs of life though – Ricoh did unveil a new wide zoom for APS-C – the HD Pentax-DA 10-17mm F3.5-4.5 ED fisheye. This year also saw a small refresh of the HD Pentax-FA 35mm F2 AL, with new coatings and a redesigned aperture diaphragm. Will we ever see a K-1 III, or a reimagined Pentax-branded mirrorless ILC? Nothing is impossible but we get the sense that 2020 will be a make or break year for the Pentax brand.

Sigma

Our 2019 resolutions for Sigma:

  • Create a range of compact F2 lenses.
  • Try again with the 24-70mm F2.8 Art.
  • Develop some native Sony FE lenses.
  • Reverse-engineer the Canon RF and Nikon Z mounts
  • Create a range of full-frame Merrill compacts.

How things panned out: 3.5 / 5

Well, either we got unusually good at guessing, or Sigma listened to us (I’ll leave you to figure out which is more likely) because of our five resolutions for Sigma in 2019, three of them became reality. This year we saw the porting of Sigma’s popular DC DN range of fast prime lenses to Canon’s EF-M mount (hey, they’re F2.2 equivalent), the release of the distinctive and very compact (albeit not for everybody) 45mm F2.8 for E and L-mount, and the launch of two high-performance ‘DN’ zoom lenses, also for E and L – one of which sort of counts as a second try at the older 24-70mm F2.8 Art.

The only one of our resolutions which definitely didn’t come to pass is reverse-engineering the Nikon Z and Canon RF mounts, which to be fair may be a decision out of Sigma’s hands. Meanwhile the full-frame fp earns a 0.5 for being pretty close (in spirit) to a full-frame Merrill, while offering so much more, especially to videographers.

Sony

Our 2019 resolutions for Sony:

  • Release a Cyber-shot RX1R III.
  • Create some new APS-C lenses.
  • Make your video and stills AF experience consistent.
  • Release an FE 35mm F1.8. Your non-pro and pro customers will thank you.
  • Focus on user experience.

How things panned out: 4/5

Another very good showing for the resolutions crew in the end, but Sony has been releasing so much new technology every year that we felt pretty optimistic about this one.

2019 saw the release of some really welcome E-mount APS-C lenses, including the excellent (albeit pricey) E 16-55mm F2.8. And we finally got that FE 35mm F1.8! Meanwhile the company did make efforts to improve the UX of its latest cameras, particularly in the a7R IV, which also offers a more consistent stills / video autofocus and user experience,

It’s a shame about the RX1R III, though. Maybe in 2020.

Tamron

Our 2019 resolutions for Tamron:

  • Continue developing full-frame E-mount lenses.
  • Reverse-engineer the Canon RF and Nikon Z mounts as soon as possible.
  • Resist the temptation to create large, heavy F1.4 glass.

How things panned out: 2/3

Again, the decision whether (or when) to reverse-engineer the Nikon Z and Canon RF mounts is probably down to Canon and Nikon, so we’ll let Tamron off the hook for that one. Ultimately, while the physical dimensions of the mounts themselves can be copied, the protocols governing data transfer between camera and lens are protected by IP, and licensing will happen on Canon and Nikon’s respective schedule (if it happens at all).

As for the other two resolutions, we’re pleased to see that Tamron did indeed continue to develop new native E-mount glass, in the form of the 70-180mm F2.8 Di III VXD and 17-28mm F2.8 Di III RXD. Meanwhile, the company announced three lightweight (I’ll get in terrible trouble in the comments section again if I suggest they’re ‘compact’) F2.8 primes. But alongside these small (ish) lenses, Tamron also sneaked in one of the highest-performance 35mm F1.4s we’ve ever used, in the form of the SP 35mm F1.4 Di USD.

We’ll forgive it.

Looking ahead to 2020

So there you have it – not all of our 2019 resolutions became reality, but if there’s one thing we’ve learned in 2019 it’s that we don’t always get what we want. Another thing we’ve learned is that lexicologically speaking, things get really complicated when you start trying to make resolutions, which are really requests, but also kind of predictions, on behalf of third-parties.

Lesson leaned. So what does 2020 have in store? As always, the future is hard to predict, but that doesn’t mean we can’t try. Here are some resolutions predictions from the DPReview team – feel free to add your own in the comments.

  • ‘Professional’ mirrorless ILC from Canon and / or Nikon.
  • At least one more serious DSLR from either / both of the above (in addition to the EOS-1D X Mark III and D6).
  • Computational imaging approaches will continue to make their way into dedicated cameras across the board.
  • More affordable full-frame L-mount ILC from Panasonic (and maybe an APS-C body?).
  • New X100-series or similar compact from Fujifilm (possibly with a medium format sensor?).
  • More lenses, and a sub-$ 1000 full-frame E-mount camera from Sony.

Articles: Digital Photography Review (dpreview.com)

 
Comments Off on 2019 resolutions revisited: what we hoped for, and what we got

Posted in Uncategorized

 

Nikon D850: What we hoped for – and what we got

26 Aug

Nikon D850

Nikon has formally announced its latest enthusiast DSLR – the D850. Since the D850’s development was announced earlier this year, speculation (fueled by the usual leaks) has been rife about the exact specifications of the new camera, but now it’s official!

Offering 45.7MP capture at a maximum frame rate of 9 fps, with an autofocus system inherited from the D5, the D850 looks like a hugely impressive camera. When it was first announced, we put together a wish list of features based on what we’d seen introduced in the D5 and D500, with a few guesses thrown in for good measure. Now that the D850 is official, we’ve updated that original article with a breakdown of what we guessed right, and what we got wrong. Click through to see how we did – we added additional D850 features at the end of this slideshow.

More pixels (but not too many more) – yes!

A well-processed Raw file from the D810’s 36MP sensor contains a lot of detail, but the D850 offers a bump in pixel count.

Nikon has been making 36MP DSLRs for a long time now, and we expected the D850 to offer a higher output resolution, while hoping that it wouldn’t pack in too many pixels at the expense of operational speed. And so it transpired.

The D850 features a 45.7MP BSI CMOS sensor, which promises both excellent dynamic range at base ISO and very good noise performance at high ISO sensitivities. And no, Canon die-hards, those two things do not have to be mutually exclusive.

In terms of output resolution, the D850 is second only to Canon’s EOS 5DS/R models among current full-frame cameras. It remains to be seen how the difference between 36-45MP actually shakes out in practical use, but in general, more pixels = better images – especially when that high-resolution sensor is paired with one of Nikon’s excellent new-generation fast aperture prime and zoom lenses.

The same or better low ISO DR – probably…

This shot from the D810 was exposed for the highlights at ISO 64 and selectively pushed by 4EV – while retaining highlights – post-capture.

One of our favorite things about the D810 was its incredible dynamic range at its true ‘base’ ISO of 64. If you’re a regular lurker in DPR comments threads you’ll know that whether or not you need more DR is still (for some reason) a topic of hot debate. We’ll save you a lot of research and just say once and for all that more dynamic range is always a good thing. More DR means greater potential for capturing a wider range of tones in a single, clean, exposure. In fact, ISO 64 on the D810 allowed it to compete with medium-format image quality (If you’re still unconvinced, read this).

We haven’t been able to test the D850’s dynamic range yet, but it certainly looks like the new camera’s base ISO sensitivity setting of ISO 64 is real ISO 64, which is very encouraging. It would be odd (but not unheard of) for Nikon to go backwards in terms of dynamic range in one of its flagship product lines, so pending further testing, we’re chalking this one up as a win.

The D5’s autofocus system – yes!

The D5’s 153-point AF system is superbly versatile, and much more effective in poor light than the D810’s older system.

When we first heard about the D850, we said it was a pretty safe bet that the D5’s 153-point autofocus system will find its way into the new camera, and we’re delighted to report that it has. The D850’s AF coverage is 30% broader than its predecessor, and a dedicated AF processor works alongside the camera’s Expeed 5 processor to deliver 3D AF tracking at 7-9fps, with all of the D5 and D500’s AF customization options. Impressive stuff.

That’s the spec, and we’re hoping that in use, the D850 will be able to match the D5’s state-of-the-art autofocus performance, including excellent accuracy in poor light (not a strength of the D810) and an extraordinarily capable 3D AF tracking system. Of course, the D5 and D500 are 20MP cameras, so the D850’s AF system will have to deliver pixel-level accuracy at a much higher resolution, and that’s something we hope to start testing very soon.

4K video – yes!

The D500 and D5 offer 4K video capture, with some restrictions – the D850 is Nikon’s most convincing 4K-capable DSLR yet.

It was pretty much a sure bet that the Nikon D850 would offer some flavor of 4K video capability, and here we are. Full-width (i.e., no crop) 2160p 4K capture at 30 and 24 fps. Our very brief tests suggest that the footage is assembled using pixel-binning, which isn’t perfect (we’d prefer Sony-style oversampling) but if that’s how Nikon achieved full-width capture, we’d call it a decent compromise. It’s worth noting that going by the specs, the D850 is likely to deliver superior 4K footage to Canon’s EOS 5D Mark IV, albeit without Canon’s excellent Dual Pixel autofocus system.

We wanted focus peaking for 4K capture, but alas, while peaking is available it’s only an option for 1080p footage.

XQD support – yes!

CompactFlash has been around a long time, but XQD cards are the future. The D500 offers one XQD slot and one SD slot, and we expected the D850 to provide the same configuration.

The XQD media used in the D500 and D5 is smaller than traditional CompactFlash, mechanically simpler, and much, much faster. And now it’s available in the D850, too.

Since Nikon’s early press release pitched the D850 as having ‘high-speed capabilities,’ we expected that it would at least offer a single XQD slot, probably with an SD slot as backup/overflow (like the D500). And that’s exactly what we got. With an XQD card installed, the D850 can shoot 45.7MP Raw files at 9 fps for up to 51 images before slowing to allow the buffer to clear. That’s not (quite) D5-level performance, but it’s not far off.

An articulated, touch-sensitive LCD and better live view AF – yes and no…

Just like the D500, the D850’s rear LCD is touch-sensitive and semi-articulating. This is great news, and makes it considerably more versatile for lots of different kinds of photography.

This one’s not a surprise. We had expected the D850’s rear screen to at least offer the 2.36M-dot resolution and limited touch-sensitivity features of the D5, and we’re pleased to see that like the D500, it’s articulated, too. While potentially less robust than fixed displays, tilting screens are much more useful, especially for landscapes, and indeed any tripod-mounted shooting from low or high angles.

Sadly, it doesn’t look like the D850 will offer any meaningful improvements to autofocus performance in live view and movie modes compared to previous-generation Nikon DSLRs.

Proper electronic first-curtain shutter implementation – sort, of maybe, not sure yet…

This is what mirror/shutter shock looks like at its worst. We were hoping the D850 might offer a more effective electronic first curtain shutter feature than its predecessor.

The D810 improved on the D800-series by offering electronic first-curtain shutter (EFCS) to reduce the risk of shutter shock, but in our opinion, it didn’t go far enough.

With the D850, we had hoped to see Nikon implement this feature properly, which would mean decoupling it from the mirror lock-up drive mode. Essentially we wanted it to operate much like the existing exposure delay mode, but with a much shorter delay. When the shutter button is pressed, the shutter and mirror would lock up, and the exposure would be started electronically a fraction of a second later.

The D850’s EFCS implementation looks like it’s the same as the D810, but there are indications (we’re working on confirming) that EFCS is available in the camera’s ‘Q’ advance mode, which might essentially solve the vibration issue.

Encouragingly, even in normal advance modes, while we tried to replicate the odd results we saw with some Nikon VR lenses on the D810, we didn’t observe any problems in images from the D850. Stay tuned for a proper test once we receive a reviewable camera.

Built-in Wi-Fi (and improved SnapBridge) – yes and no.

Snapbridge has improved a bit since we first encountered it in the D500, but it’s still not great. We were hoping the D850 would include a refined connectivity suite.

The D810 arrived before built-in Wi-Fi was widespread in Nikon’s lineup and we fully expected the D850 to offer built-in connectivity of some kind, as opposed to being limited to using external Wi-Fi modules. We’re disappointed to see that the D850 offers essentially identical connectivity options to the D500, via the company’s beginner-focused ‘SnapBridge’ system.

Snapbridge provides full-time Bluetooth connection but it offers limited access to, or control over, Wi-Fi. As such, it still seems like an odd fit for a camera that promises both high speed and high resolution capture, but we live in hope that – at least – the app will get an update at some point in the near future.

Improved Auto AF Fine Tune – no.

Auto AF Fine Tune is a great feature, but there’s room for improvement. We had hoped that Nikon would refine it in the D850, but no such luck.

The D5 and D500 introduced automated AF point calibration, but it’s not as useful – or as easy to use – as we’d like. Eventually, we’d like to see the Auto AF Fine Tune extended to all AF points, not just the center point, and we’d like to be able to calibrate for different subject distances, and for ends of a zoom lens’s range. We’d also like calibration to be made more consistent – often the obtained value varies every time you try it.

Maybe we’ll just have to wait for the D5S.

Smaller body, illuminated controls – yes!

If you’ve ever shot at night, or early in the morning, you’ll appreciate the value of backlit controls. The D850 now brings this feature into Nikon’s enthusiast full-frame lineup.

The D810 was a pretty beefy camera, and not the most comfortable DSLR to hold and use for extended periods of time. We were pleased to see that the Nikon D850 has been slimmed-down a little, in the same way as we’ve seen previously with the D750 and D7500. It’s much more comfortable to hold than the older model.

Another feature that we’re glad to see included in the D850 is backlit controls, inherited from Nikon’s professional-grade DSLRs. The ability to illuminate key control points is extremely useful for low light and night shooting.

Any other business, 1: Speed

A continuous shooting rate of 9 fps for 45MP Raw files means that you’ll probably need to budget for a couple of extra XQD cards…

The D850 doesn’t just offer high resolution, it also boasts an impressively fast maximum shooting rate. Straight out of the box, the D850 can shoot at a maximum frame rate of 7 fps, but add the optional MB-D18 grip, and add the D5’s EN-EL18b battery (shown above) and this jumps to 9 fps. If you’re shooting to an XQD card, you can expect bursts of more than 50 Raw files at that rate before the camera needs to pause for breath.

As such, assuming that the D850’s autofocus system can compete with the D5’s we’d expect the D850 to be a highly competitive DSLR for sports and action shooting.

Any other business, 2: Fully electronic shutter

We don’t have a picture of the D850 with its mirror locked-up so we’re using this generic shot of the sensor instead.

As well as fully mechanical and electronic first-curtain shutter options, the D850 can also capture images in fully electronic shutter mode in live view. In this mode, images can be captured at full resolution at up to 6fps, and up to 30fps at 8.6MP. While potentially very useful for some kinds of photography, there is a major penalty in terms of rolling shutter.

Our observations suggest that the read-out rate is somewhere between 1/5-1/10sec, which risks delivering quite wobbly images unless your scene is entirely static. It can be fun though.

Any other business, 3: lovely viewfinder, no flash

It’s impossible to tell from this image but the D850’s viewfinder is very large, and very lovely.

While not the kind of feature that we’d expect to generate many headlines outside of specialist press, the D850’s viewfinder is pretty special. At a magnification of 0.75X, the D850 offers the biggest viewfinder image of any Nikon DSLR.

To keep the size of the viewfinder assembly manageable, (albeit still large enough to preclude a built-in flash) Nikon has used a complex optical arrangement, including an aspherical element. The end result is a beautifully large, sharp viewfinder image.

Any other business, 4: 8K time-lapse movies

The D850 can create 8K timelapse movies in-camera, with metering sensitivity down to -3EV.

We were half expecting this feature after Nikon released its D850 teaser video and here we are. The D850 can utilize its built-in interval timer to create 8K time-lapse movies, at an output resolution of 8256 x 5504 pixels.

And for all of the die-hard stills folks out there that scoff at such things, there are plenty of videographers that will be intrigued by the possibilities of post-capture cropping and panning that such high-resolution output makes possible. Your mileage may vary.

Any other business, 5: Focus Shift

The D850’s Focus Shift mode allows you to capture up to 300 images, with minute focus shifts between each exposure.

Also new in the D850 is a feature that Nikon is calling ‘Focus Shift’. Similar to focus stacking features we’ve seen before in Olympus mirrorless cameras, in this mode the D850 can capture a series of images (up to 300, in fact) with minute adjustments in focus between exposures. The resulting sequence is not stacked automatically in-camera, but is saved to a specific folder on your memory card that Nikon claims can be recognized by specialized third-party software.

This feature could potentially be very useful for some kinds of macro photography (the image above is a conventional single-exposure capture) where deep depth of field is difficult or impossible due to diffraction.

Any other business, 6: AF joystick

The D850 now features a dedicated AF point positioning joystick, just like its big brother the D5.

It didn’t occur to us when we put together the original version of this article, but if the D850 inherited the D5’s autofocus system, it would make sense for it to also include the D5’s dedicated AF positioning joystick. And there it is! Just below the AF-On button. From our experience with the D5 and D500, having a dedicated control point for AF positioning is a real time-saver in some situations.

Articles: Digital Photography Review (dpreview.com)

 
Comments Off on Nikon D850: What we hoped for – and what we got

Posted in Uncategorized